After Hours Claims hours 5:00 PM to 8:00 AM
To file an after hours claim:
- 1st Choice 1-800-326-4968
- AIC 1-800-841-5241
- Allied 1-800-282-1446
- American Collectors 1-800-360-2277 till 7pm
- Amerisafe 1-800-699-6240
- Brethren Mutual 1-800-241-2541
- Brethren Mutual (Automotive Glass) 1-888-254-7604
- Buildersrisk 1-800-987-3373
- Cumberland Insurance 1-866-794-6399
- Everett Cash Mutual 1-800-326-4968
- FirstComp 1-888-500-3344 till 7 pm
- Foremost 1-800-527-3907
- Goodville Mutual 1-877-445-5780
- Knightbrook 1-800-394-3770 till 5 pm
- Lebanon Mutual 1-800-514-6072 leave a message
- Lititz Mutual 1-855-725-5642
- Progressive 1-800-274-4499
- SWIF 1-888-388-7943
- Westfield Insurance 1-866-937-2663
- Westfield Defender 1-866-937-2663